Months after the Union schooling ministry wrote to the distinguished Indian Institutes of Administration (IIMs) that the one-year-MBA diploma programmes being run by them violated norms, many of those B-schools have determined to proceed providing them, triggering a contemporary debate on the problem of their autonomy.
IIM-Indore on Monday invited contemporary purposes for its one-year Government Publish Programme in Administration for the yr 2021-22 whereas the IIMs at Ahmedabad and Bangalore additionally carried particulars of related programmes on their web sites.
A senior official at one of many IIMs, who requested to not be recognized, confirmed that a lot of the IIMs that have been providing the one-year MBA diploma course have determined to pursue the matter with the ministry and in the meantime “proceed with the programmes”.
“The ministry raised objections to the one-year course and that’s being mentioned together with with the ministry. In the meantime, a number of of the IIMs are persevering with with the course. Among the IIMs are additionally maintaining aspirants up to date in regards to the standing by way of caveats,” added this particular person.
One such warning/caveat was seen on the IIM-Bangalore web site within the part the place it gave particulars of the one-year course.
“IIM-B is working with all the opposite IIMs to interact with and tackle the issues of the MHRD associated to the programme. The ultimate construction of the programme (diploma /diploma) will rely on the end result of the mentioned interplay,” the warning mentioned.
IIM-Ahmedabad has a related caveat in a brochure on the one-year diploma programmes.
Senior officers from IIM-Ahmedabad, Bangalore and Indore when contacted weren’t keen to talk on the matter on file.
“There’s a view among the many IIMs that they’ve autonomy in such issues. Additionally they will take up any problem with ministry if required,” mentioned a second senior official of one of many IIMs who didn’t want to be recognized.
In June, the Union schooling ministry wrote to the B-schools saying they can not provide one-year publish graduate levels in administration and will comply with the College Grants Fee (UGC) rules which don’t enable this .
The ministry mentioned it sought the opinion of the legislation ministry on the matte and that the latter’s really helpful was in opposition to one-year levels.
The schooling ministry mentioned that the standard of levels may very well be compromised if the period have been curtailed.
When contacted , an official on the schooling ministry mentioned there isn’t a change within the ministry’s place.
“The ministry has already made the place clear,” added this one that requested to not be named.
The IIM Act of 2017 granted degree- giving powers to the 20 IIMs who’re the nation’s premier B-schools. Nonetheless, after the passage of the act, which gave educational autonomy to those administration institutes, a debate has raged on whether or not the IIMs can even determine to offer one-year publish graduate diploma programs. Publish graduate programmes often have a period of two years.
Among the IIMs have been of the opinion that they have been empowered to problem one-year levels .
Schooling ministry officers, nonetheless, have argued that the issuance of one-year levels additionally creates a precedent. If the IIMs can problem such levels, then different establishments may additionally need to, they argue. And it the programme will be one-year lengthy, then how lengthy earlier than somebody decides to make it six-months lengthy? The UGC Act defines the period of programmes.
Specialists mentioned one-year course could find yourself “diluting” levels.
“A one-year PG MBA diploma at this stage is academically incorrect. It’s true that since 2017, IIMs have been given educational autonomy but it surely mustn’t end in diluting their levels. In NEP2020, there are provisions for three- or four-year UG programmes. One yr MBA programme after 4 years of UG could also be justified. However that scenario shall come up after few years, not now,” mentioned professor Inder Mohan Kapahy, a former UGC member.